Storms start to move out of Minnesota, continue for western Wisconsin

MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all. 

Turn Up Your Support

The backers of a controversial, $45 million proposed resort expansion outside Ely and near the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness have asked a judge to withdraw their permits, after the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources sued to block the project. 

Owners of the more than century-old Silver Rapids Lodge, between White Iron and Farm Lakes, proposed building a new lodge and restaurant, renovating a motel, and building 49 new “fractional share” cabins, each of which would have four different owners. 

While some area residents supported cleaning up and updating the historic resort, others decried the development, saying it would bring increased visitor and boat traffic to a quiet area near the wilderness. 

Lake Minnetonka in the North Woods? Ely cabin owners push back against resort plan

Lake County officials approved the project in September after a series of public meetings, but a local conservation group, along with the Minnesota DNR, sued, arguing that the proposal violates county ordinances developed in the 1990s in conjunction with the DNR to regulate shoreland development.

A few weeks after the lawsuits were filed, project developers submitted court documents to surrender and terminate the conditional use permit and planned unit development approvals they had received from Lake County. 

In an email, Duluth-based developer Sandy Hoff confirmed that he and his partners — along with the county — had voluntarily rescinded the permit approvals.

Judge Eric Hylden has not yet ruled on the request. The Minnesota DNR wants the case to continue, out of concern that the permits could still remain in effect, and the developer or the county could move forward with similar plans at a later date. 

Hoff said the developers “do not have alternate plans at this time.” 

In court filings, project developers said they planned to pursue improvements to the resort that were “allowed under existing rights or a scaled down project with fewer units.”

Dan Kraker

Author

Backers of a proposed $45 million expansion of Silver Rapids Lodge near the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness have dropped their plans after a lawsuit from the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. 

Backers of proposed resort expansion near Ely drop plans amid state lawsuit

Go Deeper.

Like this?